Healthy Bones: More Than a Calcium Supplement

Healthy Bones: More Than a Calcium Supplement

When most people think “bones,” the next thing that comes to mind is “calcium.” If you are in your menopausal or pre-menopausal years, it is one of the things your personal physician most undoubtedly has recommended you take daily.

Calcium is absolutely an important mineral in our body—it is not only important for bone health, but also the health of the nervous system, muscles, heart, blood, skin, hair, and nails, among many other functions.

But the problem is that if you take calcium alone or in excess, the calcium will likely not go to the right places in the body, and may even build up in the wrong places, causing issues like accumulation in arteries or the kidneys.1

To avoid this, rather than consuming large amounts of a nutrient all at once in a day (like with a calcium supplement that contains a whopping 1000 mg of calcium) Ayurveda generally recommends acquiring our nutrients in small doses throughout the day with whole foods, including herbs.

Whole foods contain other minerals and vitamins that act like messengers or vehicles, assisting in the proper absorption and assimilation of calcium in the body.

Healthy Bones was therefore not designed to be just another calcium supplement. Banyan wanted a product that supported the human bone structure with supplements similar in nature and composition to actual human bone, and synergized with herbs that help maintain bone health at the core of the human body—the digestive tract.

A Spotlight on Coral Calcium

The first ingredient in Healthy Bones is coral calcium. Coral calcium is not just calcium—it contains minerals that are found in similar proportions in the human body.

The minerals in coral improve the bioavailability of calcium, as described by the mineral wheel, which shows how the many minerals in the body depend on each other to create a balanced physiology.

Mineral wheel
The mineral wheel illustrates which minerals interact with one another in the body.

Compared to many calcium supplements, which often contain calcium carbonate derived from limestone, coral calcium is derived from a living source.

What Is Coral Calcium?

A coral reef is made up by colonies of sea anemone-like creatures called polyps. These individual organisms take in minerals from the ocean that they then deposit as a type of hard crystalline structure—coral calcium.2

This structure is technically considered an exoskeleton of the polyps, and it is what is eventually harvested for calcium after it has fossilized, thousands of years later.

The Benefits of Coral Calcium

Because of the digestion process of the polyps, coral calcium is unique in its ionic, easily absorbable form. This results in a form of calcium that synergizes beautifully with the human body.

In one small study, when 20 healthy adult volunteers ate coral-added crackers, the absorption of calcium (as measured by the increase in urinary calcium excretion) was significantly greater than when those same individuals ate calcium carbonate-added crackers. The study found similar results with magnesium absorption.3

Consider the following microscopic images. The first image shows coral calcium and the second shows calcium carbonate. Note how porous the coral calcium is. Compare these images with the microscopic image of human bone, which is also porous and similar in structure to the coral calcium. The porosity allows the minerals to better dissolve.

Further, Ayurveda has a rule of “like increases like.” Because of the similar structure and qualities, according to this rule, the human bone should assimilate the coral calcium better than calcium carbonate derived from limestone.

Microscopic images of coral calcium and calcium carbonate
Figure 1: Microscopic images of coral calcium and calcium carbonate.4
Microscopic image of human bone
Figure 2: Microscopic image of human bone.5

Is Coral Calcium Vegetarian?

While the question of whether or not coral calcium is suitable for vegetarians has seen some debate, the general consensus is that it is not vegetarian or vegan. As the exoskeletal structure created by living polyps, coral is derived from an animal and therefore not suitable for vegetarians.6

That said, some vegans and vegetarians may feel okay about using coral calcium, with the understanding that it is harvested long after the living creatures have died naturally, and with no interference to their natural habitat.

Sustainability of Banyan's Coral Source

As you read this, if you are concerned about the sustainability and preservation of Earth's natural coral, rest assured we had this same exact concern.

There certainly are some coral supplements that have been harvested from coral below sea level, which does destroy living reefs and upset ecological balance. That's why we chose a source of coral that utilizes fossilized, ancient reefs that have been geologically pushed above ground thousands of years ago.

Synergizing with Ayurveda's Ancient Herbs

Weak bones are more often than not caused by high ether and air elements, or vata. Ayurveda also explains that the colon has an intricate relationship with bone, and its health is of utmost importance when it comes to bone health.

Not surprisingly, the colon is the seat of vata and plays a role in the absorption of many of the minerals and vitamins important to bone health. This is why we have chosen the herbs in Healthy Bones to complement the coral calcium.

Ashwagandha. As a fantastic pacifier of vata and nourisher of the body, ashwagandha is naturally excellent for bone health. For instance, the major constituent, withaferin A, has been shown to support the cells that naturally create bone tissue, which are called osteoblasts, and decrease the activity of the cells that naturally break down bone tissue, which are called osteoclasts.7

In one study of laying hens, the hydro-alcoholic extract of ashwagandha improved the retention of calcium and phosphorus in the tibia bone.8

Arjuna. Arjuna is similarly known to support bone health, along with strengthening the heart and circulatory system.

Ginger. Ginger is a great herb for detoxification and cleansing, particularly in the digestive tract. A healthy colon and digestive tract is a key factor in maintaining bone health.

 

Ashwagandha, arjuna, and ginger

Ashwagandha, arjuna, and ginger create a synergized herbal blend that supports complete absorption of the coral calcium.

How to Get Your Daily Dose of Calcium

Each serving of Healthy Bones (two tablets) provides 218 mg of calcium. The daily recommended allowance for calcium ranges from 1000–1300 mg. Therefore, if you were to take two servings of Healthy Bones, you would get roughly 43.6% of the daily recommended amount of calcium.

Getting the remaining 564 mg or so of calcium can be done easily in a number of ways. Here are a few examples of calcium derived from whole foods.9

  1. 1 cup of milk (300 mg)
  2. 1 cup of yogurt (450 mg)
  3. 1 ½ ounces of mozzarella cheese (350 mg)
  4. 1 cup of dried figs (300 mg)
  5. 4 ounces of soft tofu (120-390 mg)
  6. 1 ounce of whole roasted sesame seeds (280 mg)
  7. 1 cup of cooked spinach (240 mg)
  8. 1 cup of cooked amaranth (270 mg)

About the Author

Vrinda Devani, MD, AP

Vrinda Devani, MD, has a passion for women's health and empowering women towards vibrant health and living. She is a believer in unfolding the...

Read More
Recommended

References

1 Patti Neighmond. “Too Much Calcium Could ause Kidney, Heart Problems, Researchers Say,” NPR, Your Health, accessed April 11, 2017, http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2012/08/13/158506960/too-much-calcium-could-cause-kidney-heart-problems-researchers-say

2 Tamura, Lori. “Coral Exoskeleton Growth Begins inside Living Tissue.” ALS, October 18, 2021. https://als.lbl.gov/coral-exoskeleton-growth-begins-inside-living-tissue/.

3 Ishitani K, et al. “Calcium absorption form the ingestion of coral-derived calcium by humans.” J Nutr Sci Vitaminol (Tokyo). 45, no 5 (October 1999):509-17.

4 Stephan Holt, “Coral Calcium,” Health Totem, April 4, 2017, http://www.healthtotem.com/en/coral/c_micro.html

5 “AFM and SEM Imaging of Bone.” Paul Hansma Research Group Department of Physics, UC Santa Barbara, April 4, 2017, http://hansmalab.physics.ucsb.edu/afmbone.html

6 “Coral Calcium Supplements - Not Suitable for Vegetarians and Here's Why...” Vegetarian Society, n.d. https://vegsoc.org/lifestyle/coral-calcium-supplements-not-suitable-for-vegetarians-and-heres-why/.

7 Khedgikar, V, et al. “Withaferin A: a proteosomal inhibitor promotes healing after injury and exerts anabolic effect on osteoporotic bone.” Cell Death Dis. 4 (August 22 2013):e778

8 Tahmasbi AM. “The effects of phytase and root hydroalcoholic extract of Withania somnifera on productive performance and bone mineralization of laying hens in the late phase of production.” Br Poult Sci. 53, no 2 (2012):204-14.

9 “Calcium Content of Foods,” UCSF Medical Center, accessed April 11, 2017, https://www.ucsfhealth.org/education/calcium_content_of_selected_foods/